 |
| Panel Chair, Dr
Donald Slack, presented the CCER report to ICARDA staff on 7
April |
A Center-Commissioned External Review
(CCER) of ICARDAs natural resource management and socioeconomics
research took place from 28 March to 7 April 2005 at the Centers
headquarters. The CCER Panel was chaired by Dr Donald Slack, Professor
and Head, Department of Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering, University
of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona, USA. Dr Patrick Cunningham, Professor
of Animal Genetics, Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland and formerly
Director of the Animal Production and Health Division at FAO; Dr Fatima
Nassif from Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, Settat,
Morocco; and Dr Peter Midmore, Professor of Applied Economics, School
of Management and Business, University of Wales Aberystwyth, U.K.,
served as Panel members. Dr Kjersti Larsen, ICARDA Board member, served
as Observer on the Panel.
On behalf of the ICARDA Director General, Prof. Dr Adel El-Beltagy,
the Assistant Director General (Research), Dr William Erskine, welcomed
the Panel and gave an overview of ICARDAs research program.
He said that the Center aims to assist countries in CWANA to achieve
the Millennium Development Goals, especially those related to eradicating
extreme poverty and hunger, ensuring environmental sustainability
and building a global partnership for development. ICARDA is working
in a region which has many challenges, including high population growth
rates, water poverty, climate variability and change, inadequate food
and feed, desertification, loss of biodiversity loss, migration and
unfavorable international trade regimes. ICARDA sees potential to
alleviate the problems in the region through scientific agricultural
research on improved technologies and natural resource management
practices, diversified farming systems, and improved vertical integration
from producer to consumer.
Dr Erskine emphasized that by working in partnership with national,
regional and international agricultural research institutions, ICARDA
is able to identify priority issues and implement collaborative research
activities in a cost-effective way. He also explained to the team
the steps taken by the Center to implement recommendations of the
External Program and Management Review (EPMR) of 2000. Examine
what we are doing, whether we are doing it well and achieving results,
he urged the Panel.
Explaining the new programmatic thrusts of ICARDA, Dr Erskine said
that the Center's new research portfolio focuses more on poverty alleviation,
taking into consideration the priority concerns of the people in CWANA,
using new tools of science and enhancing integration of the work of
the Center to make a difference. He informed the Panel that ICARDAs
research portfolio has been re-organized into six mega-projects, four
of which focus on thematic areas of management of scarce water resources
and mitigation of drought; integrated gene management; improved land
management to combat desertification; and diversification and sustainable
improvement of rural livelihoods in dry areas. The other two are cross-cutting,
focusing on poverty and livelihood analysis, and knowledge management
and dissemination. ICARDA has also commissioned CCERs on its training
and germplasm programs, Dr Erskine said.
Dr Richard Thomas, Director of the Desertification Mega-Project, and
former NRMP Director, explained the evolution of NRMP. He told the
Panel that ICARDA has worked with various partners, including those
in the CGIAR system, to elaborate the Integrated Natural Resource
Management approach in agricultural research. INRM is an approach
that integrates research on different types of natural resources into
stakeholder-driven processes of adaptive management and innovation
to improve livelihoods, agroecosystem resilience, agricultural productivity
and environmental services at community, ecoregional and global scales
of intervention and impact, he said.
ICARDA scientists made presentations to the Panel on several areas
of research, including socioeconomics research activities related
to natural resources, production systems and policy and public management;
agroecological characterization; water resource management; land and
soil conservation; sown pasture and forage production; native pasture
and rangeland management; small ruminant production; and agronomy
of production systems. The Panel also visited Khanasser Valley, ICARDAs
integrated research site in Syria, to see the implementation of the
INRM approach.
Panel Report
Our task has been to look with honest eyes and say it as we
see it, Dr Slack, Panel Chair, said in a meeting with ICARDA
staff on 7 April. Our consensus is that the Natural Resources
Management and Socioeconomics scientists have responded in a very
positive manner to the EPMR recommendations.
The CCER recommendations, listed below, were jointly presented by
the Panel members, according to his/her area of expertise.
Continue and intensify ICARDA research to better use wastewater
as a source of water for irrigation
Develop and implement appropriate integrated impact assessment
methods that correspond to the
INRM approach
Intensify economic and social analysis of the barriers to adoption
of existing proven technologies
Secure a critical mass of social science researchers with the
required competence profiles to allow
timely delivery, continuity, and high quality output
Monitor progress on refereed journal publication so that a
satisfactory level of at least two refereed
journal publications per person per year is achieved
Review the management and functioning of the mega-project structure
to promote simplicity in lines of
responsibility and reporting
Establish a Research Internship Program which would bring young
scientists from the weaker NARS to
work with scientists at ICARDA for a period of one to
two years
Undertake a benchmark study to (a) estimate change
in agricultural productivity, (b) identify the
significant new challenges that have emerged and, (c)
provide a base-line for ICARDAs future programs
Dr Larsen thanked the CCER Panel for their effort. I feel very
privileged to have been a part of this process, she said. On
behalf of Prof. Dr Adel El-Beltagy, ICARDA Director General, Dr William
Erskine, ADG-Research, thanked the Panel for their recommendations
and the ICARDA staff for their cooperation throughout the review process.
The full CCER report will be presented to the Board of Trustees at
its annual meeting scheduled for the last week of this month. |
|
|
About
ICARDA: Established in 1977, ICARDA (www.icarda.cgiar.org)
serves the entire developing world for the improvement of barley, lentil,
and faba bean; and dry-area developing countries for the on-farm management
of water, improvement of nutrition and productivity of small ruminants
(sheep and goats), and rehabilitation and management of rangelands. In
the Central and West Asia and North Africa (CWANA) region, ICARDA is responsible
for the improvement of durum and bread wheats, chickpea, pasture and forage
legumes and farming systems; and for the protection and enhancement of
the natural resource base of water, land, and biodiversity.
The Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) (www.cgiar.org) is a strategic alliance of countries, international and regional organizations, and private foundations supporting15 international research centers that mobilizes cutting-edge science to promote sustainable development by reducing hunger and poverty, improving human nutrition and health, and protecting the environment.
|